Use the Interactive App

For the full interactive experience with comments, bookmarks, and more features, open this article in our app:

Open in App

Live Debate: Did the Muhammad of Islam Exist?

jay smith debatedid muhammad exist debateislamic history debatemuhammad historical existencechristian muslim debateislam originsjay smith islamhistorical muhammadstreamyard debatereligious debate 2025islam critiqueapologetics debatelive debate islammuhammad of islamjay smith vs raymond epriormuslim christian dialogueyoutube live debatehistorical criticism islamraymond ibrahimdavid woodrobert spencerholy war

Debate Topic: Did Muhammad of Islam Exist? Date & Time: August 21st at 3:00 PM Eastern Standard Time Debaters: Jay Smith @pfanderfilms vs. Raymond Ibrahim @Ray

Debate Topic: Did Muhammad of Islam Exist?
Date & Time: August 21st at 3:00 PM Eastern Standard Time
Debaters: Jay Smith @pfanderfilms vs. Raymond Ibrahim @RaymondIbrahim-HW
Moderator: Hatun Tash
Join us for an engaging and thought-provoking live debate as Jay Smith and Raymond Ibrahim examine the controversial question: Did Muhammad of Islam truly exist as portrayed in Islamic tradition?
This debate will feature structured opening statements, rebuttals, closing remarks, and an audience Q&A session. Your participation and respectful engagement in the live chat are welcome.
If you have questions for the debaters, feel free to leave them in the chat during the Q&A segment.
Raymond Ibrahim will go first.
Debate Structure:
• 20 minutes opening statements (each)
• 2 rounds of 10-minute rebuttals
• 8 minutes closing statements
• Audience Q&A
video is edited out: tech issues at the beginning and break before Q&A
Be sure to like, comment, and subscribe for more content on historical debates and religious discussions.